Venezuela Spotlight: UM Study Finds More Stress among Migrants in Colombia than in U.S.

Once Latin America’s wealthiest nation, Venezuela is now an economic and political shell of its former self. As Venezuelans continue their mass exodus for survival, newly published research by a public health researcher and developmental psychologist at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, reveals surprising news about this population’s levels of self-reported stress in their new homelands.

Seth J. Schwartz, Ph.D., presenting his research findings.

In the first-ever research study of Venezuelan immigrants in South Florida and Colombia, Seth J. Schwartz, Ph.D., director of the Ph.D. Program in Prevention Science and Community Health in the Miller School’s Department of Public Health Sciences, and his collaborators investigated a question of cultural context: Do Venezuelan immigrant groups migrating to areas more culturally similar to their own report less discrimination, and a less negative context of reception, compared to immigrant groups settling in countries that are more culturally dissimilar?

Their results showed that Venezuelan immigrants in Colombia reported significantly greater discrimination, a worse context of reception, and more depressive symptoms compared to their counterparts in the U.S. The full research summary was published in the November 2018 issue of the International Journal of Intercultural Relations.

“We believed that newer Venezuelan immigrants in Colombia — a country with more cultural similarities to Venezuela than the U.S. — would report less cultural and psychological distress than their peers who emigrated to American cities,” Dr. Schwartz said. “We based our hypothesis on Cultural Stress Theory, which holds that more similarity between one’s heritage and one’s destination society would decrease those feelings.”

Dr. Schwartz and his collaborator, Christopher Salas-Wright, Ph.D., at Boston University, studied survey responses from 647 Venezuelan immigrants. The sample was divided evenly between immigrants surveyed in Bogotá, Colombia, and those surveyed in Miami. The majority of immigrants studied had migrated within one year prior to taking the survey. The study focused on individuals who were parents, because Venezuelans often migrate as family units.

Participants were asked to report their feelings of perceived discrimination, negative perceptions of how they were received and viewed, and symptoms of depression and anxiety. Dr. Schwartz’s team collaborated with the Nuevos Rumbos Corporation to collect data on the Colombian side of the investigation.

“Given the language differences and the anti-Hispanic sentiment in the U.S., we had believed that Venezuelan immigrants in the U.S. would report significantly more discrimination, and a more unfavorable context of reception,” Dr. Schwartz said. “Our data showed a different result.”

Why the Differences?

The findings suggest that mechanisms other than cultural similarity and dissimilarity may be responsible for the observed differences.

According to Dr. Schwartz, some of the factors may have included:

• The long history of rivalries between Colombians and Venezuelans in trade, sports and politics.

• South Florida’s status as home to large groups of Venezuelan immigrants since the late 1990s. The newer Venezuelans entering America may have existing connections and networks of support already in place.

• The earlier Venezuelan immigrants to South Florida, who were highly educated business people and professionals. Their social status may have created a more positive pre-existing perception of Venezuelans for South Floridians.

• The fact that the majority of Venezuelans entering Colombia are less educated and from lower incomes, creating an actual threat to low-wage Colombians for jobs.

• Colombian politicians, who have made the Venezuelan wave of immigration into a hot political issue — whipping the public into a frenzy as to how to resolve the “threat.”

Dr. Schwartz added that the past two to three years represent the first time mass immigration of any kind has hit Colombia’s borders — a very different scenario than in the U.S.

“Imagine you are a Colombian citizen, living your everyday life,” he said. “Suddenly 500,000 foreigners show up in under a year, and into a space only as large as Texas, Arizona, and Oklahoma combined. That’s equivalent to about five million new immigrants entering America in the same period — five times our annual average.”

Social and Economic Fallout in Both Countries

Dr. Schwartz emphasized that the mass influx of low-wage and poor Venezuelans into Colombia — a country that has far less opportunities to begin with — has created fierce competition for any and all employment.

“Even the Colombian prostitutes are fighting for their lives,” Dr. Schwartz added. “The newly arrived Venezuelans have taken a large part of that industry over — desperate to do anything at all for money to feed their families. It’s also common to see women, men and children living in the streets, begging.”

Venezuelan emigres to the U.S. also are hitting hard times. Dr. Schwartz explained that many highly educated former professionals from Colombia lost their life savings in the Venezuelan economic crash. They fled to South Florida with nothing more than the clothes on their bodies, their belongings stuffed into suitcases.

“These are doctors, scientists, engineers, now literally sleeping in their cars,” Dr. Schwartz said “There are many people so malnourished that you can see bones through their skin.”

He added that the current American climate on asylum and shifting policies is making a bad situation worse. Many of the Venezuelans coming to America are applying for asylum and potentially facing deportation — a return to their homeland where inflation is above 1,000 percent and prospects are grim.

Spreading Awareness

The report was part of larger pilot study on the experiences of Venezuelan immigrant parents in the U.S. (Florida, especially Miami-Dade and Broward Counties) and Colombia (Bogotá, the capital city). So where do the social and psychological scientists wish to go from here?

“We want our research to help spread awareness of a major social issue occurring in both countries,” Dr. Schwartz said. “Since publishing, we’ve already received many calls and emails from social and economic scientists asking us how they can help.”

One of his own goals is to begin a formal lobbying campaign.

“As we continue additional research, we will make more noise about the impact of this situation and the importance of ensuring opportunities,” he said. “Many of these individuals have so much to contribute to our country. There is no organized movement to help them, but we plan to change that.”